Lately I've been on a baking kick. It started with wanting to be able to eat muffins. I really like muffins! But it's hard to fit them into my diet anywhere without adding extra calories. I decided that if they were healthy muffins, they could easily count as breakfast... right? First I made muffins with shredded carrots and applesauce, and they came out really good. Then I bought a "501 muffins/scones/pastries" book and have made a different kind of muffin every week.
Thing is, only so many of the recipes in the book are for "healthy" muffins; you know, low fat with lots of fiber. I've gradually been learning how to make healthier substitutions. The first thing I learned was to swap out oil for applesauce, then to use whole wheat flour in place of some of the all-purpose. Now I also add bran (the first few recipes had it in the ingredients list already, but now I've learned how to incorporate it whether it's called for or not) and am getting to the point that I'm ready so start experimenting with honey instead of sugar. I've already been using brown sugar instead of white when I think it will work well with the other flavors in the recipe. Here are some of the tips I've used:
Applesauce for vegetable/canola oil
As long as you are okay with the slight change in taste and texture (typically sweeter and softer), you'll have the best success substituting applesauce in oil-based baked goods, like quick breads, muffins and some cakes.
But let's get one thing straight: applesauce is not a great substitute for butter, and will lead to disaster in cookies and any other treat with a crispy snap. Unless you like cake-y, mushy cookies.
Most sources recommend a 1:1 swap: if the recipe calls for 1 cup of oil, substitute with 1 cup of applesauce. If recipe is too moist, you may want to reduce the amount of applesauce by as much as 1/3.
More tips for substitute success:
* Use unsweetened applesauce, or reduce the amount of sugar in the recipe if you use sweetened applesauce.
* Measure applesauce in a liquid measuring cup.
* Use a hand or stand mixer to thoroughly combine the applesauce with the other liquid ingredients (egg, flavoring), then blend the liquids with the sugar. With a large spatula, carefully fold the dry ingredients into the mixture until just combined.
* The finished product will be moist. Don't alter the time for cooking because low-fat recipes dry out when they're over-cooked.
Whole Wheat for White Flour
Whole-wheat flour usually can be substituted for part or all of the all-purpose flour in most recipes. If a recipe calls for two cups flour, try one cup all-purpose and one cup whole-wheat. When completely substituting whole-wheat for white, use 7/8 cup whole-wheat for one cup of white flour.
Products made with whole wheat flour will usually be more dense. This may be helped somewhat by sifting the flour one or two extra times to help incorporate more air. Using a combination of regular and whole wheat flour will produce a lighter result. Aim to replace about 1/2 to 3/4 the white flour with whole wheat.
Always remember when using any all purpose flour for items such as muffins and cookies to mix as little as possible to avoid forming glutens, which will toughen the final result.
Wheat Bran/Wheat Germ for flour
Replace up to 1/3 of the flour with Wheat Bran/Wheat Germ (Wheat Bran/Wheat Germ can substitute for each other in equal amounts).
Brown Sugar for White Sugar
In spite of their difference in weight, you can substitute brown sugar for granulated white on a 1 to 1 basis, and the most significant difference will be taste. Pack the brown sugar firmly into the cup. Brown sugar includes molasses, which adds moisture, so it will keep baked goods from drying out so quickly.
Honey for White Sugar
To start with, it's a good idea to substitute up to half of the sugar in a given recipe. Once you've experimented more and have a better handle on how it works, you can try a higher percentage.
Up to one cup, honey can be substituted for sugar in equal amounts. For example, you can substitute 1/2 cup of honey for 1/2 cup of sugar called for in a recipe. Over one cup, use about 2/3-3/4 cup of honey for every cup of sugar. This is because honey is actually sweeter than sugar.
Honey is a liquid, so you'll need to reduce the liquid in the recipe a little. Do this at a rate of 1/4 cup less liquid for every cup of honey used in the recipe. Honey browns faster than sugar so lower the temperature of the oven by 25 degrees and watch closely in the final few minutes of baking. Honey is also a little acidic. To counter-act this, you may need to add 1/2 teaspoon of baking soda for every cup of honey used.
Whipping or heavy cream
Equal amounts evaporated skim milk OR 1/2 low-fat yogurt + 1/2 low-fat cottage cheese
Sour Cream
Substitute plain yogurt in equal amounts.
Options for reducing fats in a recipe
Start by just replacing half the amount of fat with an equal amount of any of these options:
- Fruit purees like unsweetened applesauce, canned crushed pineapple, or mashed bananas. Use an old banana for sweetness and banana-y flavor, a green banana for all the nutrition without competing flavors.
- Vegetable purees like sweet potato, cauliflower, or canned pumpkin. Also try shredded veggies, like the familiar carrots or zucchini. Though technically a fruit, don't forget about mashed avocado! Save the darker veggies like spinach puree to combine with chocolate desserts or with a darker fruit like blueberries.
- Beans, my personal favorite option. Beans add protein and structure to a recipe and, when pureed, go completely unnoticed! Try great northern beans or pinto beans for a neutral taste, and chickpeas for a slightly nuttier taste. Use black beans and adzuki beans in recipes that call for cocoa or chocolate.
- Nut butters, like peanut butter, almond butter, or tahini. Cashew butter has a particular neutral creamy taste. These also pack in some extra protein.
An egg is 2 ounces of thick liquid, so it is best substituted with 2 oz of another thick liquid. Try any of the above fruit, veggie, bean, or nut butter substitutions listed for subbing out fats.
Nuts - reduce the amount by half and toast them.